A contractor called us recently about training videos. They wanted four of them, about an hour each, filmed over two days. Then came the question we hear a lot: could it all get done in one day?
There is a better question to answer first. Does the video need to be the whole class, or does it need to teach the class? Those are different jobs, and the answer changes how you film.
What happens to long videos
Philip Guo and his colleagues studied 6.9 million video watching sessions from four edX courses for a 2014 paper on what keeps students watching. The strongest predictor of engagement was length. Median engagement time topped out at about six minutes, no matter how long the video was. Their advice was to plan lessons in chunks shorter than six minutes.
The same study found that the share of students who went on to attempt the problems after a video fell from 56 percent to 31 percent as videos got longer.
Those were students in online courses, not crews on a job site. But an hour on a screen loses people long before the hour is up, wherever they are.
When the full class is the right call
When it is the record. Some training has to be documented as delivered. A full recording shows exactly what was taught and when.
When people missed it. A recording lets someone on another shift catch up.
When the instructor is the reason people come. Some trainers are worth an hour. Most classes were never built to be watched alone.
If any of those apply, record it. Just do not count on the recording to do the teaching.
When short videos win
If the goal is for someone to do the task right on Tuesday, short wins. One skill per video, a few minutes each, named the way people would search for it. A new hire can watch the one they need the night before, and again in the truck.
We go deeper on length in how long a training video should be. For when a clip should be a full work instruction and when it is just a reminder, see SOP vs work instruction vs job aid.

How one day can give you both
You rarely have to choose. Planned before the camera comes out, one day can capture the full class and the pieces you need to cut it into short videos.
Plan the chapters first. Mark where each topic starts and ends before filming. Those marks become your short videos.
Film by setting, not by order. When we planned an ergonomics training program for a safety consulting firm, the list came to 42 separate video assets across four main settings, from the office to production, construction and material handling, planned for one to two filming days. The only way that fits is to film everything at one setup before moving to the next.
Shoot the demonstrations separately. The class explains. The demonstration shows. Film each one as a wide, a medium and a close shot, with a few seconds of clean footage before and after each action, so an editor can build a short video around it.
Mic the instructor. A clip people cannot hear is a clip they skip.
Film where the work happens. We have helped film training videos for a commercial construction company, on site with their own crew. People pay closer attention when they recognize the place and the person.
Can it all happen in one day?
Sometimes. Four hours of finished class is four hours of camera time before a single demonstration or retake. A long day can hold it if the class runs straight through and the demonstrations are planned ahead.
At Apex Dental Laboratory Group, the shot list was a full day of work, so we planned a full day. On a half day, somebody is choosing what to drop at 4 o'clock. That one day gave them enough footage for nine videos. Training works the same way. Plan the day around what you need to end up with, then decide how many days it takes.
The same footage goes further than training, too. Short clips of your people doing the work feed onboarding, recruiting and social, and we covered the safety side in safety training video and why safety training doesn't stick.
The short version
- Long videos lose viewers. In a study of 6.9 million sessions, median engagement topped out around six minutes regardless of length.
- Record the full class when it is the record, when people missed it, or when the instructor is the reason people come.
- Break it into short videos when the goal is doing the task right.
- Plan the chapters and demonstrations first, and one day can give you both.
